Crime and the Media

Soc 3336
Spring 2011
Instructor: Jeff Maahs
Class Time and Room:5-7:40pm in Cina 224
Office Hours: Monday/Friday, 11am-noon, Wednesday 1:30pm-3pm, or by Appointment
Office: 207 Cina
Mailbox: 228 Cina
Email: jmaahs@d.umn.edu
Web: www.d.umn.edu/~jmaahs
Phone: 726-7395

Course Description

This class concerns the representations of crime and the criminal justice system in the media. Television, film, newspaper, and electronic/internet media intersects with crime and the criminal justice system in a number of important ways. The point of this course is to examine how the media represents, distorts, and/or filters crime and justice issues. Also, the media is used as a mechanism to explore issues (e.g., political ideology, corrections policy, causes of crime) that are central to the study of crime.

Course Objectives/Outcomes
Upon completing this class, students will:

1. Have the skills to critically interpret media and recognize the construction of crime and justice (e.g., cops, courts, prisons).
2. Understand how images of crime and justice vary across different forms of media.
3. Understand the role of political ideology in criminology and criminal justice and recognize ideological viewpoints in the media.
4. Determine how media coverage varies across different types of crime (e.g., white collar crime vs. street crime, violent vs. property crime).

Required Course Readings

Textbooks:
Surette, R. (2011). Media, Crime, and Criminal Justice. 4th Edition. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.

Beckett, K., and Sasson, T. (2004). The Politics of Injustice: Crime and Punishment in America. 2nd Edition. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Articles and Book Chapters (See links within syllabus calendar--see below)

Potter, G.W., and V.E. Kappeler (2006). Constructing Crime: Perspectives on Making News and Social Problems. Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press.

Cullen, FT., and K. Gilbert (1982). "Criminal Justice Theories and Ideologies." In, Reaffirming Rehabilitation. Cincinnati: Anderson.

Cullen, F.T., and R. Agnew. (2010). "The Chicago School: The City, Social Disorganization, and Crime." In, Criminological Theory: Past to Present. Fourth Edition. Los Angeles: Roxbury.

Petrosino, A., Turpin-Petrosino, C. and Finckenauer (2000). "Well-meaning programs can have harmful effects! Lessons from experiments of programs such as Scared Straight." Crime and Delinquency 46: 354-379.

Rafter, N. (2006). Shots in the Mirror: Crime Films and Society. Cambridge: Oxford University Press.

Seabrook, J. (2008). "Suffering Souls: The Search for the Roots of Psychopathy," The New Yorker (November 10).

Seagal, D. (1993). "Tales from the Cutting Room Floor: The 'Reality" of Reality-Based Television," Harper's Magazine (November): 50-57.

Toobin, J. (2007). "The CSI Effect: The Truth about Forensic Science," The New Yorker (May).

Weidner, Robert R. (2008). "Methamphetamine in Three Small Midwestern Cities: Evidence of a Moral Panic," Journal of Psychoactive Drugs 41: 227-239.


Special arrangements/Facilities

It is the policy and practice of the University of Minnesota Duluth to create inclusive learning environments for all students, including students with disabilities.  If there are aspects of this course that result in barriers to your inclusion or your ability to meet course requirements – such as time limited exams, inaccessible web content, or the use of non-captioned videos – please notify the instructor as soon as possible.  You are also encouraged to contact the Office of Disability Resources to discuss and arrange reasonable accommodations.   Please call 218-726-6130 or visit the DR web site at www.d.umn.edu/access for more information. 

Academic Dishonesty(Cheating)

Cheating on exams or assignments will be dealt with in accordance with University policies. Anyone caught cheating on an exam will receive a zero for that exam. Plagiarism refers to presenting another's words or ideas as if they were your own. It is cheating and thus an academic offense. The penalty for plagiarism is failure for that particular assignment. I encourage you to work together, but you must turn in your own work. If you use ideas or words from the texts or outside readings, you must cite the work.

Missed Assignments

All students are expected to turn in assignments on the day they are due. Failure to do so will result in substantial penalties. If the assignment is not turned in within two school days of the due date it will not be accepted.

Course Requirements

Exams: There will be a midterm and final exam for this class. The exam may be either take-home, "in class" or some combination of these two methods. Specifics for the exam will be disseminated to students as the class progresses.

Assignments: For most weeks, there will be a writing assignment based on the readings and/or course material. Most of the assignments involve answering questions designed to help you think critically about the course materials. You must complete all assignments. Assignments will be posted online at least one week prior to their due date. They are due on the calendar date where they are posted. These are meant to be exercises in ACADEMIC writing, so please follow the ASSIGNMENT GUIDELINES. You will lose points for improper citation, poor grammar, and spelling errors.

Discussion Questions: Each week, half of the students will be required to submit a "discussion question" based on the readings for that particular week. The discussion questions should be submitted via email. In the subject line, use only "DQ." For convenience, students will be assigned to one of two groups based on last names. The first group will include students with last names beginning with A-L (the AL group). The second group will include those students who have last names that start with the letters M-Z (the MZ group). The "DQ" column in the syllabus calendar indicates which group should submit the discussion question for that week. The questions must be received by the Tuesday before we discuss the topic.

Grading Scale: (Instructor reserves right to curve final grades upward)

93-100%
A
73-76% C  
90-92%
A-
70-72% C-  
87-89%
B+
67-69% D+  
83-86%
B
60-66% D  
80-82%
B-
0-59% F  
77-79%
C+
     
Assignments
35%
Midterm Exam
30%
Final Exam 30%
Discussion Questions
5%

 

 

 

Course Schedule: This course schedule is subject to change based on the pace of the course or other factors. The instructor reserves the right to add or remove readings and/or assignments. Students will be notified via email of any changes.

Date Topic Readings
DQ
Assignment
Media
     
Jan 19 Introductions + Syllabus review None
     
 
Jan 26 Ideology, crime, and criminal justice; crime and justice in the U.S..-- A reality check

Cullen and Gilbert, "Criminal Justice Theories and Ideologies"; Surette, Chapter 1; Beckett and Sasson, Chapters 1-3

AL
Assign 1 Due
     
 
Feb 2 Overview of media/crime links; social constructionism; politics of crime
PPT SLIDES
Surette, Chapter 2; Beckett and Sasson, Chapters 4-5
Potter and Kappeler, Chapter 8
MZ
Assign 2 Due
     
Feb 9 Crime waves, moral panics, and the news media Potter and Kappeler, Chapters 1-3, 10-11
AL
Assign 3 Due
     
 
Feb 16 Drug panics; meth as latest issue Potter and Kappeler, Chapters 7 and 17
Weidner, "Methampetimene in Three Small...."
MZ
No Assignment
Reefer Madness
Front Line Meth
     
 
Feb 23

Crime and justice in entertainment television intro;
Reality television--COPS and others

Surette, Chapter 4; Potter and Kappeler, Chapter 4; Toobin, "The CSI Effect, The New Yorker; Seagal, "Tales from the Cutting Room Floor," Harpers; Kohm, "Nameing, Shaming..."
AL
Assign 4 Due
COPS/AMW examples
     
March 2 Cops on the big screen Rafter, "Introduction" and "Cop Films"
MZ
Assign 5 Due
Dirty Harry
     
 
March 9 Midterm Exam None
     
 
March 16 Spring Break Avoid being part of the crime/media coverage while on spring break
     
 
March 23 Media and the court system Surette, Chapter 5
AL
 
TBD
     
 
March 30 Media and Corrections Surette, Chapter 6; Potter and Kappeler, Chapter 16
MZ
Assign 6 Due
Reality Corrections
     
 
April 6 Causes of Crime: The Psychopath

Rafter, "Slasher, Serial Killer, and Psycho Movies,"
Seabrook, "Suffering Souls," New Yorker

AL
Silence of the Lambs
     
 
April 13 Causes of Crime: The 'Hood Cullen and Agnew, "The Chicago School: The City, Social Disorganization, and Crime." (Introduction + readings).
MZ
Assign 7 Due
TBD
     
April 20 Scared Straight! and beyond Petrosino et al., "Well-Meaning Programs..."
AL
Assign 8 Due
Scared Straight!
     
 
April 27 Media as a cause of crime / public opinion Surette, Chapter 3, pp. 69-82 and Chapter 8; Potter and Kappeler, Chapter 18, Beckett and Sasson, Chapter 8
MZ
TBD
     
 
May 4 Media as crime prevention / Review Surette, Chapters 7 & 9; Beckett and Sasson, Chapter 7
AL
 
TBD
     
 
May 11 Final Exam Review Material