Evidence

Home

The Incident

The Cast

The Natural History of a Lawsuit

Legalities

• Duties
  
  Evidence
  Credibility of Witnesses
  Direct and Circumstantial Evidence
  Evaluation of Deposition Evidence
  Expert Testimony
  Impeachment
  Textbooks and Articles
  Failure to Produce Evidence- Inference
  
  Trial Instructions

[Note: Selection of the proper form and its use and modification to suit individual facts and circumstances requires careful review of all the language by the user.]

CIVJIG 12.15 Evaluation of Testimony- Credibility of Witnesses

Guidelines for evaluating testimony

You must decide what testimony to believe and how much weight to give it.

Here are some guidelines:

1. Will a witness gain or lose if this case is decided a certain way?

2. What is the witness's relationship to the parties?

3. How did a witness learn the facts? How did he or she know, remember, and tell the facts?

4. What was his or her manner?

5. What was his or her age and experience?

6. Did the witness seem honest and sincere?

7. Was the witness frank and direct?

8. Is the testimony reasonable compared with other evidence?

9. Are there any other factors that bear on believability and weight?

In addition, you should rely upon your own experience, good judgment, and common sense.